Field note ·

The questions buyers ask before signing, and what a good answer sounds like

Nobody signs a machinery contract because the brochure was good. They sign because the answers sounded credible. Here are the eight questions that separate a supplier who has done this before from one who has not.

Nobody signs a machinery contract because the brochure was good. They sign because the ans
Nobody signs a machinery contract because the brochure was good. They sign because the answers sounded credible. Here are the eight questions that separate a supplier who has done this before from one who has not.

Why the answers matter more than the specification

A specification is a document; a supplier is a set of habits. The document can be copied from a previous project, complete with requirements nobody intends to test. The habits show in how the supplier answers questions about failure, schedule and blame.

The eight questions below are not a checklist to send by email. They are a conversation, and the value is in the hesitation before the answer and in the specificity after it. A good answer names a document, a person or a date. A weak answer uses the word 'normally'.

1. What did your last project fail at acceptance, and what did you change?

A supplier with real projects has a real answer: a transfer that was mis-set, a read rate that missed the specification on printed film, a guarding gap that the safety assessor rejected. They will also describe what they changed in the design or the process afterwards.

A supplier who says nothing failed is either new, or not being told. Neither is a reason to sign: the first has no history to learn from, the second has a culture that hides problems until they are yours.

2. How is the acceptance rate measured, and on whose product?

The correct answer describes the mix, the run duration, the sampling and the instrument. It also states whose product will be used and whether the buyer must supply it. A supplier who proposes to prove the rate on a test coupon has proposed to prove the machine, not the process.

Ask what happens if the rate is 5 percent short on the day. A defined re-test with agreed remedies is a mature answer; 'we will tune it' is not.

3. Which parts of the scope are not yours?

Exclusions are the cheapest thing to clarify and the most expensive thing to leave vague. Site preparation, foundations, power distribution, compressed air, network, local labour, downstream handling and commissioning consumables should each have an owner named in the contract.

The follow-up is the useful one: ask the supplier to list the three exclusions most often forgotten by buyers in your industry. A supplier who answers that has watched those exclusions bite.

4. What is the schedule built from, and where does it have slack?

A schedule is credible when it names the long-lead items, the approval gates and the dependencies on the buyer. A schedule of bars with no annotations is a drawing, not a plan.

Ask which single item, if late, moves the whole date. The answer is usually controls hardware, a special casting or a third-party safety component. Knowing it lets the buyer protect that item, and it also reveals whether the supplier has thought about it.

5. Who does the commissioning, and who do I call at 2 a.m.?

Commissioning by the design engineer is better than commissioning by a subcontractor who has never seen the drawings, and both are better than commissioning by whoever is available. Ask for names and roles.

The 2 a.m. question is about support structure. A single phone number for a company with one engineer is a single point of failure. Ask for the escalation path and the contractual response time, then check that the response time is in the contract rather than in the presentation.

6. What is the spare parts philosophy, and what will be obsolete in five years?

A good answer distinguishes wear parts from failure parts and names the items the supplier holds in stock. A better answer states which components are commercial off-the-shelf and which are proprietary, because the proprietary ones are the future single-source problem.

Ask specifically about the controls platform and the drives. If the platform has a ten-year availability statement, that is an answer. If it has a roadmap slide, that is not.

7. What does the warranty actually cover, and when does it start?

Coverage, exclusions, remedy, response time and start date. The start date is where most disputes live: at shipment, at installation, at handover, or at first production. Each is defensible and each shifts the risk.

The remedy matters as much as the coverage. Repair, replace or credit are three different outcomes, and the supplier's preference tells the buyer how they think about downtime.

8. What would you change about our specification?

This is the question that reveals everything. A supplier who engages will name two or three things: a requirement that is over-specified, one that is under-specified, and one that will cost more than it is worth. That is engineering.

A supplier who says the specification is perfect has decided that the contract is more important than the outcome, and that is a decision the buyer will live with for ten years.

The answers we give to these eight questions, in the same order, are on our FAQ page - including the ones where the honest answer is 'it depends on your data'.

How to use the conversation

Ask all eight in one session, write down the answers, and read them back a day later. The weak ones will be obvious on the second reading, which is the point of writing them down.

Then put the load-bearing answers in the contract. An answer that is not in the contract is a hope, and hopes are not a procurement strategy.

The three answers that should end a conversation

The first is 'we have never had a failure at acceptance'. It ends the conversation because it says the supplier either has no experience or is not trusted with the truth by their own team.

The second is 'the rate is guaranteed by the sorter manufacturer'. It ends the conversation because the sorter is one layer of the system, and a guarantee on one layer does not guarantee the line - and the supplier knows it.

The third is 'the contract is our standard form, we cannot change it'. It ends the conversation because the questions above are exactly what a standard form is designed to avoid answering.

None of those answers is dishonest. Each is a decision about how the supplier manages risk, and each tells the buyer where the risk will land after signature.

Reading the contract against the answers

Take the eight answers, write them into a one-page schedule, and attach it to the contract as a statement of understanding. A supplier who will not attach it has told the buyer that the answers were conversational rather than contractual.

Check three clauses against the answers: the acceptance clause, the warranty clause and the variation clause. If the acceptance clause has no measurement method, the answer to question two is not in the contract. If the warranty clause has no remedy, the answer to question seven is not in the contract.

The reading takes an hour and it is the highest-leverage hour in the procurement. A contract that reflects the answers is a contract that can be enforced quietly, which is the only kind that is ever enforced at all.

What to ask after the site visit

After a reference visit, ask the host three questions the supplier did not prepare for: what would you change about the machine, what is the most common stoppage, and how long did commissioning actually take against the plan.

Those three answers are usually more useful than anything in the presentation, because a host who has lived with the machine has no incentive to protect the supplier. A reference that refuses those questions is not a reference.

Ask the supplier afterwards what the host said and whether it matches. A supplier who knows the reference site's complaints has a relationship; one who is surprised has a logo on a slide.

The answer that should reassure you, and the one that should not

'We do not know yet, and here is how we will find out' is a strong answer. It names a method, a date and an owner, and it is what an engineering team sounds like before it has your data.

'That will not be a problem' is a weak answer, because it closes a question instead of answering it. On a machinery project, almost everything is a problem somewhere, and a supplier who has done this before knows which parts.

What to check

  • Ask what failed at the last acceptance and what changed.
  • Define the acceptance rate: mix, duration, sampling, instrument, whose product.
  • Get every exclusion an owner.
  • Ask which single item moves the schedule.
  • Put coverage, remedy, response time and warranty start date in the contract.